FAQ

Hippocampome FAQ

Project Design

Q:     Why do some neuron types with identical morphological patterns, for example CA1 Basket and Axo-Axonic cells, form separate neuron types in Hippocampome.org?

Q:     Several of the earlier hippocampal anatomy studies also employed guinea pigs - is there a plan to include these data as well?

Q:     How are data from different articles linked? 

Q:     If a new paper publishes data on cells with axonal/dendritic branching in SMo that lumps together cells that have no projections to Sub with those that do (i.e., DG Neurogliaform and MOPP), will the data be linked with both, or only one of the two cell types defined in the knowledge base?

Q:     Reference is made to MEC LII stellate cells but EC LIII pyramidal cells [without the M], and EC LII basket-multipolar [without the M] but MEC LIII superficial trilayered interneurons. Is this intentional?

Curation

Q:     Who is doing the annotating and review of the knowledge base?

Q:     How frequently is the literature surveyed to update the knowledge base?

Q:     Are there any mechanisms for Hippocampome.org users to suggest the inclusion/review of specific articles?

Electrophysiology

Q:     For electrophysiology data, why are rats preferred over mice and other rodent species?

Neuron Term Portal

Q:     How are the definitions in the Neuron Term Portal derived?

Collaborations

Q:     Does Hippocampome.org collaborate with any other web sites?

Future Directions

Q:     There is no mention of gap junctions - will these data be added later?

General

Q:     Which browsers are formally supported by Hippocampome.org?

 

 

 

 


 

Project Design

Q:     Why do some neuron types with identical morphological patterns, for example CA1 Basket and Axo-Axonic cells, form separate neuron types in Hippocampome.org?

A:     Although the main categorization property is axo-dendritic pattern, the secondary properties listed below are sufficient to uniquely separate neuron types.  Such significance is placed on these secondary properties because they can dramatically affect the behavior of the type in a neuronal network. In the case of CA1 Axo-axonic cells, they specifically target the axon initial segments of CA1 Pyramidal cells and ignore any other targets.

          -Primary neurotransmitter: e.g., CA1 Cajal-Retzius and CA1 Neurogliaform

-Targeting specificity: e.g., CA1 Axo-axonic and CA1 Basket

-Consistently differentiating patterns of biomarkers and/or electrophysiological properties: e.g., CA1 Basket and CA1 Basket CCK+

Q:     Several of the earlier hippocampal anatomy studies also employed guinea pigs - is there a plan to include these data as well?

A:     We curate information on rodent species; consequently, information from guinea pigs is included.  Because this information has been infrequently encountered, it is sparse in the knowledge base.

Q:     How are data from different articles linked? 

A:     All data in Hippocampome.org are linked to a neuron type.  This can be accomplished directly by presentation of a reconstruction, schematic, or text description of the neuron; or indirectly by a citation that provides such a description.  In two special cases, data can be linked in the absence of a description of the axo-dendritic pattern.

          The special cases rely on identification by other prominent characteristics of the neuron type: 1. soma location in the principal cell layer for DG Granule and CA1, CA2, and CA3 Pyramidal neuron types, where they make up 90% or greater of the cell bodies; and 2.  axonal tracts for DG Granule (mossy fibers) and EC hippocampal projecting types (perforant path).

Q:     If a new paper publishes data on cells with axonal/dendritic branching in SMo that lumps together cells that have no projections to Sub with those that do (i.e., DG Neurogliaform and MOPP), will the data be linked with both, or only one of the two cell types defined in the knowledge base?

A:     The data will be putatively linked to both cell types as long as the formal link can be made to both.

Q:     Reference is made to MEC LII stellate cells but EC LIII pyramidal cells [without the M], and EC LII basket-multipolar [without the M] but MEC LIII superficial trilayered interneurons. Is this intentional?

A:     Yes, it is intentional. We assign the prefix MEC to neurons that have been characterized solely (or are known to exist predominantly) in the Medial Entorhinal Cortex, such as layer II spiny stellate cells. Similarly, the prefix LEC is assigned to lateral entorhinal neurons. In contrast, neurons that are believed to exist in both the medial and lateral entorhinal cortices are given the prefix EC.

 

Curation

Q:     Who is doing the annotating and review of the knowledge base?

A:     Currently, the annotation and review of  the knowledge base is performed by the authors of the publication (D. W. Wheeler, C. M. White, C. L. Rees, A. O. Komendantov, D. J. Hamilton, G. A. Ascoli "Hippocampome.org: A knowledge base of neuron types in the rodent hippocampus", under review).  In the future, we will endeavor to include mechanisms for direct input from the user community.

Q:     How frequently is the literature surveyed to update the knowledge base?

A:     The current plans are for quarterly surveys of the literature.  A log will be kept that tracks which new articles are being considered for inclusion into Hippocampome.org during a future update.

Q:     Are there any mechanisms for Hippocampome.org users to suggest the inclusion/review of specific articles?

A:     Users can utilize the Feedback button in the main banner to address new or currently included articles.  In addition, we are automatically made aware of any PMID for which a user searches that is not in the knowledge base.

 

Electrophysiology

Q:     For electrophysiology data, why are rats preferred over mice and other rodent species?

A:     Although more rat electrophysiological data than mouse exists in the literature (77% of the electrophysiological parameters sets were taken from rats, 20% from mice, and 3% from guinea pigs), Hippocampome.org curates both and has a substantial amount of mouse information.  In the electrophysiological table for legibility reasons, it is only possible to display one value.  To determine the display value, we prioritize rat, patch-clamp, and body temperature data.  However, clicking on any value will display all of the information, including any from mouse (and from sharp electrodes, room temperature, etc.).  Moreover, we have plans to make the species displayed a selectable user option.

 

Neuron Term Portal

Q:     How are the definitions in the Neuron Term Portal derived?

A:     The definitions are derived from 26 sources: BIOPORTAL, CRISP, Gene Ontology, Hippocampome.org, MeSH, NCBI Gene, NCBI Protein, Neurolex, Protein Ontology, Allen Brain Atlas, ChEBI, MBF Bioscience, Medical College of Wisconsin, Merriam-Webster Medical, NeuroElectro, NIST InChI Trust, Scholarpedia, UTHealth Neuroscience, Wolfram MathWorld, Cambridge Dictionaries, Macmillan Dictionary, Merriam-Webster Dictionary, Oxford Dictionaries, TheFreeDictionary, Wikipedia, Wiktionary.

 

Collaborations

Q:     Does Hippocampome.org collaborate with any other web sites?

A:     We fervently think that scientific progress is significantly expedited by information sharing.  Two examples of collaborative relations are with NeuroElectro and NIF. 

Hippocapome.org shared mined electrophysiological data with NeuroElectro in May 2014 as a ‘gold standard’ testbed to help validate the NeuroElectro automated literature mining protocol. We will continue to monitor future updates of NeuroElectro content for new additional information related to hippocampus neurons.

We have given NIF scraping access to our website for inclusion of Hippocampome.org content in their search portal.

 

Future Directions

Q:     There is no mention of gap junctions - will these data be added later?

A:     Yes, we are in the early stages of annotation information concerning gap junctions and other synaptic information, which will be added to Hippocampome.org in future updates.

 

General

Q:     Which browsers are formally supported by Hippocampome.org?

A:     Hippocampome.org formally supports current versions of Firefox, Chrome, Safari, and Explorer.